Skip to product information
1 of 5

BUFFALO ELK - Mens Deck Shoes by Orca Bay Brown Leather

BUFFALO ELK - Mens Deck Shoes by Orca Bay Brown Leather

  • Last / fit shape: Orca Bay does not publish a last number for the Buffalo; this style is widely sold as a roomy fitting with a rounded country-shoe profile.
  • Materials: Full-grain oiled pull-up leather in the Elk colourway, with a full leather lining and footbed.
  • Upper details: Hand-stitched three-eyelet docksider with rawhide lace.
  • Sole type: Deep-tread commando-style rubber sole.
  • Fitting: Generous fitting.
  • A proper chunky-soled deck shoe for men who want more grip and more country mileage than a flat-soled boat shoe usually gives.

Please note: leather, nubuck and suede colours may vary slightly due to natural batch differences and your screen settings.

SKU: md-buff-elk-41
Regular price £115.00
Regular price Sale price £115.00
Sale Sold out
Taxes included. Shipping calculated at checkout.
Quantity
Free UK shipping on orders over £100
🔁 Easy 30-day returns
🔒 Secure checkout — Credit/Debit Cards & PayPal accepted
🤝 Friendly, UK-based support

Extended Description

BUFFALO ELK - Men's Orca Bay Walking Shoe

  • Classic leather docksider style shoe with non-marking commando style sole
  • Hand-Stitched in premium quality leather with a leather lining
  • 3-Eyelet shoes designed and finished to a superb standard
  • Made in EU sizes 40 - 47 with half sizes
  • Supremely comfortable and tough, hard wearing country shoe
  • Great as a walking shoe or on-board deck
  • Premium quality leather for durability
  • Fully Leather lined for extra comfort
  • Hand Stitched for superior craftsmanship
  • Extremely comfortable for all-day wear
  • Very Hardwearing for long-lasting use
  • Available in EU sizes 40-47 with half sizes (UK 7-12)

Why this pair stands apart

The Orca Bay Buffalo takes the old docksider pattern and gives it more bite underfoot. In Elk, the upper is a full-grain oiled pull-up leather with the sort of grain and colour movement that looks better once the leather starts to live a bit. It keeps the hand-stitched moccasin character of a proper deck shoe, but the heavier commando sole gives it a more useful footing for daily wear on pavements, quaysides, gravel and country lanes.

Construction that suits the job

This is not a closed-channel, welted country shoe, and it should not be sold as one. Its strength is different. The upper is hand stitched, the lining and footbed are fully leather, and the rawhide lace keeps the pattern true to the classic three-eyelet docksider brief. The result is a shoe that feels breathable, flexible and far less stiff than a bench-made welted shoe, while still carrying enough substance for regular hard wear.

Fit and the question buyers actually ask

The fit story here is reassuring. Public feedback is mostly positive, with buyers describing the Buffalo as comfortable, ideal in fit. Allow a short wear-in period so the leather can mould properly to your foot. 

How to wear it

The Buffalo works best as a country-minded casual shoe: with denim, cords, moleskin trousers, chinos or shorts by the coast. It has enough heft for everyday use and enough deck-shoe character to avoid looking like a technical walker. If you want one pair that can move from town to harbour to weekend pub lunch without changing stride, this is exactly the lane the Buffalo sits in.

Care

Treat the Elk upper as smooth pull-up leather. Brush off grit, wipe lightly after wet wear, then use a conditioner/polish sparingly to keep the leather fed without drowning the finish. Cedar shoe trees will help hold the toe shape and draw out moisture between wears.

Care guide

Leather Shoe & Boot Care Guide: How to Clean, Condition & Protect Leather Footwear

High-quality leather shoes and boots are an investment, offering superior durability, comfort, and timeless style. With proper care, they can last for decades, developing a beautiful patina over time. Here’s how to keep your Blake-stitched or  Goodyear welted, full-grain leather shoes and boots looking their best.


1. Remove Dirt & Dust with a Horsehair Brush

Before applying any polish or conditioner, it’s crucial to remove surface dirt and dust.

  • Use a horsehair brush to buff away dirt.
  • For tougher grime, wipe with a damp microfiber cloth, but avoid soaking the leather.

Pair your horsehair brushes with a soft microfiber cloth or cotton duster for gentle cleaning and buffing.


2. Conditioning: Keep Leather Supple & Prevent Cracking

Leather naturally loses moisture over time, which can lead to drying and cracking. A high-quality leather conditioner helps restore essential oils and keep the leather soft.

How to Condition Leather Shoes & Boots:

  • Apply a small amount of leather conditioner using a cotton cloth / duster or your fingers.
  • Massage it into the leather using circular motions.
  • Allow it to absorb for at least 15 minutes.
  • Buff off any excess with a horsehair brush for a natural sheen.

A leather conditioner and horsehair brush are must-haves for proper leather care.


3. Polishing: Restore Shine & Enhance Colour

Leather polish enhances the appearance of your shoes while adding a layer of protection.

Choosing the Right Polish:

  • Cream Polish: Nourishes and restores colour without excessive shine.
  • Wax Polish: Provides a high-gloss finish and extra protection.

How to Apply Polish:

  1. Apply a thin layer of polish with a cotton cloth or polish applicator brush.
  2. Let it sit for 5-10 minutes.
  3. Buff using a horsehair brush for a classic shine.
  4. For a mirror shine, apply multiple thin layers, buffing with a soft cloth after each application.

A leather polish kit (cream & wax), polish applicator brush, and buffing cloth create the perfect polishing routine.


4. Waterproofing & Protecting Leather Shoes

Exposure to water and harsh weather can damage leather. To protect against rain, stains, and moisture, use a leather protector spray or dubbin wax.

  • For smooth leather: Use a water-repellent spray that won’t alter the finish.
  • For rugged boots: Use dubbin wax for a heavier layer of protection.

How to Apply Waterproofing Products:

  • Spray or rub a small amount evenly over the surface.
  • Let it dry fully before wearing.
  • Reapply every few weeks or after exposure to wet conditions.

A leather protector spray or dubbin wax ensures your shoes stay protected all year round.


5. Caring for the Soles & Welt

  • Clean the edges of the sole using a damp cloth and mild soap.
  • Condition leather soles with a sole dressing to prevent drying out.
  • If the soles show excessive wear, take them to a professional cobbler for resoling.

Using cedar shoe trees helps absorb moisture and maintain the structure of your shoes.


6. Proper Storage & Maintenance

  • Use cedar shoe trees: These absorb moisture, prevent creasing, and help maintain the shoe’s shape.
  • Store in cotton shoe bags: This protects against dust and light exposure.
  • Rotate your shoes: Wearing the same pair every day reduces their lifespan—allow at least 24 hours between wears.

A combination of cedar shoe trees and cotton shoe bags extends the life of your leather footwear.


Essential Leather Shoe & Boot Care Kit (Recommended Products)

  • Horsehair Brush – For cleaning and buffing.
  • Leather Conditioner – Prevents cracking and keeps leather soft.
  • Cream Polish & Wax Polish – Enhances colour and provides protection.
  • Polish Applicator Brush & Buffing Cloth – For even polish application.
  • Leather Protector Spray / Dubbin Wax – Shields against water and stains.
  • Cedar Shoe Trees – Maintains shape and absorbs moisture.
  • Cotton Shoe Bags – Protects from dust and scuffs.

By following this leather shoe care routine, your high-quality Goodyear welted shoes and boots will remain in top condition for years, developing a rich patina that enhances their character over time.

Sizing

Sizes
We recommend using our foot measure to accurately measure your feet. Note:
The internal shoe size is between 5mm and 10mm longer than your foot length in mm
NOTE: EU sizes do NOT correspond directly to UK sizes
Additionally different manufacturers use different sizing scales, different lasts (height and width) and different toe gaps.
Bear in mind new shoes can be stiff at first and pull off at the heel leading to people thinking they are too big, If they do pull off at the heel - give them a good bending and try them on again.
But also bear in mind Orca Bay shoes do loosen up after being worn in.
 
The scale below is indicative as many variables come into play.
 
Our foot measure devices have a cm/mm ruler down the middle for accurate measurements

UK EU Foot Length (mm)
4 37 229-237
5 38 237–245
6 39 240–255
6.5 40 250–255
7 41 255–265
7.5 41.5 265–270
8 42 265–275
8.5 42.5 270–275
9 43 275–285
9.5 43.5 280–285
10 44 285–290
10.5 45 285–290
11 45 290–295
11.5 46 295–300
12 46 295–305
13 47-48 305-315

Attributes

  • SKU: md-buff-elk-41
  • EAN / Barcodes:

    • 40: 5055585805125
    • 41: 5055585805132
    • 41.5: 5055585805149
    • 42: 5055585805156
    • 42.5: 5055585805163
    • 43: 5055585805170
    • 43.5: 5055585805187
    • 44: 5055585805194
    • 44.5: 5055585805200
    • 45: 5055585805217
    • 46: 5055585805224
    • 47: 5055585805231
Questions & Answers loading...
£115.00
View full details
  • FREE

    UK Mainland shipping see bar above....Read More

  • Returns

    No Quibble returns/exchanges ...Read More

  • EU/Export Customers

    Not duty paid. You are responsible for duty, vat & brokerage fees charged by couriers & your Government......Read More

  • Ask a Question ?

    If you have any question  ...Here

These deck shoes earn high praise for exceptional comfort and durability. Customers said they are "incredibly hard wearing" and last for years with proper care. The interior comfort and quality construction are consistently highlighted. However, some shoppers note the shoes are heavier than expected for their style.

  • 5 stars: 111 (86%)
  • 4 stars: 14 (11%)
  • 3 stars: 3 (2%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 1 (1%)
Some of the reviews shown are from related products the merchant grouped with this one.
L
LP

They've ridden the highways and byways of the American West. Castrated cattle in Nevada. Shot a bear in California. Sailed the great Mississippi River. Cycled across Turkey. Summitted volcanoes in Galapagos. Waded the mangroves for crocodiles. Sailed across the Atlantic twice. Swum in the Caribbean, frequented fancy cocktail bars across the Mediterranean, backpacked in the Philippines and been clubbing in London. Stalked deer in Scotland and shot pheasant in Shropshire. Scaled cliffs in Cape Verde. Climbed a 14,000ft mountain in Colorado, Snowdon and Munros. And they're still going strong. Razor cut soles, laces still going strong and eyelets not rusted. I've averaged a different country every 6 weeks for the last 7 years and they've been along with me for the ride since 2022 as my main shoes. I had them polished once by a shoe shiner in Turkey in 2024, they looked brand new. We then went and sat in the middle of a roundabout in central Istanbul to drink beer in a bush, the only place his wife wouldn't find him. Oh. They've also jumped out of a plane from 12,000 feet

Wow, it sounds like you and your CREEK Orca Bay Deck Shoes have been on quite the adventure together! It's amazing to hear that they have stood the test of time and accompanied you on all of your travels. We're so glad to hear that they are still going strong and have even been polished to look brand new. That's truly a testament to their durability and quality. Thank you for choosing CREEK and for taking us along for the ride. Safe travels!

S
Sharon Dirkin

These deck shoes are supremely comfortable and have less clumpy soles than a lot of models. I have bought 2 pairs.

A
Anonymous

I usually only buy from the Crieff Shop. in person, but this time I ordered on-line. It was a very quick and efficient service which is always appreciated

Thank you for your kind words! We're delighted to hear you had a positive online shopping experience with Cathcart Elliot. We look forward to serving you again.

M
Michele Smith

Great shoes, really comfortable from day one

M
Michael Cohen

Very pleased with the Orca Bay Kip loafers.
Only just wide enough for my H width right foot , but will accommodate with wear.
Thanks for your prompt and efficient service.

Hi Michael, thank you for your kind words and for choosing Cathcart Elliot. We're happy to hear you're pleased with the Kip loafers and appreciate your feedback on the fit. They will definitely ease up with use.

J
John Coll

These will be my wife's second pair of Orca Bay Deck shoes and I understand that she is very pleased with them.

P
Penny

Excellent shoes, rapid despatch. Good company. Recommended.

A
Anonymous

excellent

A
Anonymous

These are simply gorgeous shoes. Thank you.)

G
G.A

Very good quality shoes. Interior is very comfortable.

P
Pamela Sheppard

Good service. Excellent quality. Lovely fit and very comfortable. A good looking shoe.

A
Anonymous

Straight forward to order and excellent time delivery. Thank you

M
Maryam Coles

Unfortunately had to return, very narrow fitting.

D
David Lee

Arrived in good time. love the casual Nubuck finish and so comfortable.

A
Anonymous

Just whatI was looking for !

F
Fiona W.

Very good comfortable leather boat shoe

J
John B.

Good quality shoe all as described dispatched and delivered promptly.

C
Caley M.

My husband has worn only these shoes for years - smart, comfortable, durable - perfect.

N
Nigel S.

Nice comfortable shoes.

J
Jonathan L.

Orca deck shoes are very comfy and look really nice too.
I may just swap out the leather laces for normal ones if I can find some the right size.

J
Jane N.

Very tight and small no size on them so I think they are a 38?

K
Karen G.

Really pleased with my shoes, excellent service provided, arrived promptly, wouldn't hesitate to use again. And would define recommend to friends.
Many thanks

E
EMW Squires

I like buying from Cathcart Elliot. They sell quality products and are professional, with a smooth, easy-to-follow website and a fast reliable service. I have no hesitation in recommending them.

J
Joe B.

Appeared to be well made but very small fitting and I could not get them on so had to return them.

A
Ash S.

Great price and fast delivery. Very satisfied thank you.

B
Brenda D.

This was a repeat purchase.
Very comfortable
Hard wearing
Long lasting
Have been looking out for replacement for some time.
Delighted to have found them.
Thanks.

r
richard w.

Good thank you

J
Janet E.

Beautifully made shoes, they fit without sizing up and so far are good.
Bit too early to comment on durability.

J
Janet E.

They are really well made and comfortable; immediately.
These are my 2nd pair, and after 9 years of continuous wear of the first pair and still going, I was SO pleased that the fit and style were still available, with no subtle changes.
I have now introduced my husband to them, he seems pleased, fingers crossed.

P
Peter J.

Great deck shoes a cut above Sebargo Chatham and Duberries

A
ANTHONY U.

Excellent shoes from Orca Bay, comfortable straight out of the box!

Questions & Answers loading...